Which of the follow...
 

Hello and welcome to Psychology Roots Forums! We are thrilled to have joined us in this space dedicated to all things related to psychology. Participating in forums can be a great way to learn from others, share your own experiences and knowledge, and connect with like-minded individuals. You can engage in discussions on topics ranging from the latest research in psychology to practical tips for improving mental health.

We also invite you to take advantage of the resources available on our website, including articles, videos, and recommended readings. With so much information at your fingertips, Psychology Roots Forums is the perfect place to begin or deepen your exploration of psychology.

Which of the following is the strongest piece of evidence for the idea that animals are capable of developing and using a sophisticated language?

1 Posts
1 Users
0 Reactions
273 Views
(@aamir)
Posts: 2889
Member Admin
Topic starter
 

Which of the following is the strongest piece of evidence for the idea that animals are capable of developing and using a sophisticated language?

(A) The discovery of physical structures in animal brains are analogous to the language acquisition device in humans.
(B) Primates quickly learn words that result in food rewards.
(C) Systems of communication have been documented in species from honeybees to dolphins.
(D) Apes have been able to use the words they know to express novel concepts.
(E) Young apes and young humans pick up new vocabulary at similar rates.

Spoiler
Answer
(D) Apes have been able to use the words they know to express novel concepts.

Spoiler
Explanation
One of the more impressive feats cited by those who believe that animals are capable of true language is that some apes have been able to use words they were taught to express novel concepts. For instance, Washoe, who didn’t know the word for refrigerator, was able to describe it as a “cold box.” Chomsky speaks of a language acquisition device, but the term does not refer to a physical structure in the brain. Even though primates are able to learn words that result in food rewards, critics of the idea that animals have language say these words are merely the result of operant conditioning and do not evidence true language. There is no doubt that animals including honeybees and dolphins can communicate with one another and with people to some extent; however, there is much debate over what should be considered “language.” Young apes are much slower to pick up new vocabulary than are young humans.


 
Posted : 11/05/2024 8:21 pm
Share: